| Please CLICK HERE to go to the updated guitar forum. This version is no longer active as a discussion area, but is still available as a searchable archive. All user names and passwords have been integrated in the new forum |
|
Acoustic Guitar Forum
![]() The IGS Guitar Forum
![]() Charango tunings?
|
| next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: Charango tunings? |
|
Tom Austin Member Posts: 3404 From: Occidental, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
Hi all, I just put down my new charango to type this. Boy, I love that thing. But here's the deal: I got this as a birthday gift and went to the web page(http://www.rumillajta.com/) of the place she bought it from. There, they instructed me of the proper tuning: EAECG. All string pairs unison except the center pair, which is an octave. I haven't tried that tuning yet. I'm still using the one I THINK Bob showed us at his last weekend workshop: DGBEC. As I remember it, Bob had them tuned "like the four high strings of a guitar plus a C." Do I have this right, Bob? and what of the tuning on the web page. I seem to remember you mentioning that you could tune it "like a ukelele plus one", but I don't remember specifically enough. My guess is that EAECG is the "standard" charango tuning, and DGBEC is an alternate tuning. If that's true, are there other alternate tunings? any good place for more info? chords in either tuning (the web site has some good ones for "standard" tuning). Lastly, it seems pretty tough to keep in tune. There's not much sustain, and I haven't played nylon strings regularly in 17 years. Are the strings just stretching or should I prepare to keep a very close eye on the tuning? Btw, it's not a cheap charango. The workmanship and parts are very, very good. IP: Logged |
|
Bob Brozman Member Posts: 2590 From: Brozmanistan, Earth Registered: Nov 1999 |
Hi Tom, I only meant the RELATIONSHIP between the 2nd to 5th strings were like the highest 4 strings. I tune as follows (from face to feet)backwards from how you wrote it in your posting. F Bb D G D (5th to 1st). These 2 tunings are the same, just the second one is a step higher. Either one sounds great, the higher one is brighter, but I feel is a little dangerous in hot climates! I have had 3 charangos explode already, one in Calcutta, One in Okinawa, and on on Reunion. I don't know any alternate tunings, there is so much to explore in this one! An "Em" fingering in the low tuning is concert Gm. A "G" fingering yields Bb. Same fingerings in the higher tuning yield concert Am and concert C, respectively IP: Logged |
|
Leo Stepanek Member Posts: 700 From: Innsbruck, Austria Registered: Apr 2000 |
Hi Bob and Tom, funny to read about the misunderstanding of tunings. Generally it seems that the latin part of the world (South America and some parts of Europe) describe tunings from high to low (or from feet to face, which considering the tuning of the charango, is more appropriate - gratulations Bob for bringing it to the point) while english, german and scandinavian speaking people rather think the other way round. Don't know about other cultures, though. By the way, charango explosions don't seem to be limited to hot climates. Mine exploded in Innsbruck, Austria, during wintertime. We definitely don't have a hot climate here in winter (some even doubt that summers in Innsbruck do justice to their name). Because of the order of the charango strings I tune them to a guitar as follows: lower middle string: same as E (1st) on guitar higher middle string and next-to-feet pair: an octave above E (1st) next to face pair: an octave above G string of guitar second-next-to-face pair: tune to 5th fret of charango G pair Second-next-to-feet pair: tune to 2nd fret of charango G pair Besides the guitar-like relation between the four string-pairs next to the face there's also a mandolin like relation betweeen the two pairs next to the feet. End of confusion. IP: Logged |
|
Tom Austin Member Posts: 3404 From: Occidental, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
aha. I thought I might have misunderstood. I also got an extra set of strings, and on the back it instructed EAECG. Considering that Spanish Grammar often puts words "backwards" in relation to english I might have guessed it was bottom-to top on the strings. I myself always get confused when telling other guitar players "second string, third fret" or whatever. Even if I'm "right", I'm worried that they won't know the high E = bottom string = first string combination. I think it's down to the high string being on the bottom for confusing me. So anyway, I'll go re-tune my charango and try again. I think, though, that I have indeed discovered an alternate tuning - DGBEC works pretty well. This may be why it's not staying in tune, however.
IP: Logged |
|
Tom Austin Member Posts: 3404 From: Occidental, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
upon further reflection, I realize my DGBEC "alternate" tuning is not very alternate. Change the C to a B and you have DGBEB, three or five half-steps down from "standard" charango tuning. In other words, standard tuning detuned a step and a half with a half-step tweak on the highest string. So I can still use the chords I worked out with the "wrong" tuning if I change what I do on the highest string by one fret. Which is too bad for the "C" chord shape I was using. Now I have to fret the first string, first fret, which makes that position much harder to do. I'll figure something out for that. But I can use the chords from the www.rumillajta.com website. I still notice that my charango detunes itself a good step/step-and-a-half after I put it down for a couple of hours. Which means I can't just pull it off the wall and play it, but need to carefully tune each time I play. Not a bad thing, I guess. Is this normal for charangoes? are the strings just settling in, maybe? IP: Logged |
|
Jeffrey Sipress Member ![]() Posts: 1335 From: Santa Barbara, CA Registered: Nov 1999 |
Well, I have an old charango with old strings that I have not yet made the time to learn. Can't stop playing guitar. But I have found some information about it. Hope to learn a little at IGS. Check out: [URL=http://www.ancient-future.com/links/index.html] [URL=http://www.music.gla.ac.uk/HTMLFolder/Research/UGResearch/Daniel/htm/charango.htm] [URL=http://www.geocities.com/Yosemite/4301/elcharango.htm] [URL=http://www.rumillajta.com/meto.html] [URL=http://www.rumillajta.com/prosol.html] [This message has been edited by Jeffrey Sipress (edited 07-10-2000).] IP: Logged |
|
Tom Austin Member Posts: 3404 From: Occidental, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
great links, Jeffrey. yeah, I know what you mean. When I pick up my charango, my National feels neglected, and so does my wood guitar, and my electrics, and my basses. Repeat ad infinitum. IP: Logged |
|
Corn Dog Member Posts: 1765 From: Montclair, NJ USA Registered: Jan 2001 |
I need help from the Charango experts. I have come across conflicting tuning information that I need to reconcile before I blow up my Charango. There's a tuning listed at ancient-future that is an octave lower than Leo's posted tuning for some strings. Which is more correct or traditional? Leo's sounds wonderful (like a Mando) but I don't want to break the charango. See following links for further clarification of the question: To see and hear the difference: If that does not work on your computer, you can see it here: Thanks for your help! [This message has been edited by Corn Dog (edited July 23, 2002).] IP: Logged |
|
mikeln Member ![]() Posts: 420 From: Poway, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
I use Broz's tuning: F Bb D G D (low to high) It's lower, and lessens the "implosion" factor. I find the "fun" factor of the charango is finding which note to add on the high string...you can create some very rich chords by either:1) not fingering it (drone) or 2) no playing the same note as the 3rd string. Simple example (single tone calypso "Uncle Joe" or "Blow Wind Blow"): (I say psuedo 'cause the real chord depends on your tuning...). IP: Logged |
|
mikeln Member ![]() Posts: 420 From: Poway, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
And to answer your question: F = 2nd fret E string on guitar (1st string high string) Your example is incorrect...guitar music is written 1 octave higher than it sounds...so [This message has been edited by mikeln (edited July 23, 2002).] [This message has been edited by mikeln (edited July 23, 2002).] IP: Logged |
|
Corn Dog Member Posts: 1765 From: Montclair, NJ USA Registered: Jan 2001 |
Mikeln: Thanks for responding so thoroughly. Unfortunately, I've only seen intro information about tuning pitches written relative to the piano and standard notation. It didn't occur to me that they were using guitar specific notation to identify the pitches. I guess the description of it as a ten string lute was the clue I missed. When you're tuned down, do you find it more difficult to vamp on a tune in E or A? I'm assuming you don't capo these suckers. I've tuned down to your tuning and my charango doesn't seem to resonate with it as well as the standard one. I've had this experience with guitars as well. Sometimes they just don't respond as well to certain tunings. Thanks again! [This message has been edited by Corn Dog (edited July 23, 2002).] IP: Logged |
|
mikeln Member ![]() Posts: 420 From: Poway, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
Maybe the "F" tuning is better on the Large bodied Charango. I'd say, find the tuning that sounds the best on your charango. (Right now, mine has detuned itself down to "E"...still sounds good). When I play "duets" with a guitar, generally the guitar capos up. Don't generally try to play concert pitch. IP: Logged |
|
Adrian Freed Member ![]() Posts: 2360 From: Berkeley, CA, USA Registered: Oct 2000 |
mikeln, how do you finger that pseudo Am? Also I think you mean 12024 and 12020 for the psuedo B7. IP: Logged |
|
mikeln Member ![]() Posts: 420 From: Poway, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
Geez Adrian...bring up an old old thread! You are correct about the ~B7 on my website: www.charango.org it is correct. Also ~Am ==> 2210x Never have figured out a good thing to do with that high string as this: ( 22101 ) is very hard to finger and so is: ( 22105 )... IP: Logged |
|
Adrian Freed Member ![]() Posts: 2360 From: Berkeley, CA, USA Registered: Oct 2000 |
Old thread? Well, yes - sorry about that, but as many of you know I am a slow learner and I just got around to owning a charango. I did find out something interesting in my wanderings around the web. It is traditional to change Charango tunings according to the season. I suspect the tradition may be a practical matter and may help avoid the widely reported exploding charango problem. I am hoping my intuition and Bob's advice is correct that you want to tune down during dry weather but maybe humidity weakens them? Clearly, minimizing temperature and humidity changes is a good idea for any string instrument. [This message has been edited by Adrian Freed (edited September 09, 2003).] IP: Logged |
|
mikeln Member ![]() Posts: 420 From: Poway, CA, USA Registered: Nov 1999 |
~Am... This may also be usable: 22155 or the "easy" Am7 one: 55555 IP: Logged |
|
Adrian Freed Member ![]() Posts: 2360 From: Berkeley, CA, USA Registered: Oct 2000 |
22155 is workable with partial barres with middle finger and little finger. Incidentally the best site I have seen so far for Charango is IP: Logged |
|
dieg0 New Member Posts: 2 From: Pasadena, California Registered: Jan 2006 |
Hi - I'm finally getting to the charango I was given 20 years ago (no joke). Any charanguistas in Los Angeles California? Thanks. dieg0 IP: Logged |
|
Massiel New Member Posts: 2 From: Armidale Registered: Mar 2006 |
quote: IP: Logged |
|
Massiel New Member Posts: 2 From: Armidale Registered: Mar 2006 |
Hello, I gather when you say explosion you mean the strings all popped off together attached to the wooden bridge? Mind did, and just when I started to make some interesting sounds... I just got it back from repairs, and the first thing they asked was the Charango hot when it exploded...did you notice that with yours? My Charango was bought in Chile after searching what seems like every little town from Argentina to the mid North Chile for a decent one...so I was quite frustrated when it exploded. The idea of playing it like a guitar crossed my mind. I may try that one because I am so much more comfortable with the guitar settings. But holding the darn thing is a challenge....its so awkward to hold. Cheers & greetings from Armidale
--
Massiel Barros IP: Logged |
|
john brenton New Member Posts: 2 From: fresno ca eeuu Registered: Mar 2006 |
i may be late with my response to the charango tuning dilemma... To reply the best I can, I am more or less a concert charanguista I just returned from peru and ecudor, kind of a music tour. The problem with charango tunig is that there a million tunings, all from various regions and communities...there are many tunings that are good for different things. If you are playing traditional folklore, if you play contemporary andean music, or if you are playing anything from jazz to your own creations. The most basic, and easiest to play with guitar tuning is the GCEAE going from lowest to highest. However, you may not have this size of charango. a "charango" can be various sizes, depending region...any smaller than this range is "waylacho", and larger than this range is "ronroco." for example, i have one charango that two frets less, and one that is one less than the common charango...beautiful, but i need to transpose to play...if you have a charango that sounds bad or loose on the G string, i recommend tightening that string until you get a good yet not to tight vibration, and then tuning the rest accordingly. for the best tuning resource, i suggest www.pacoweb.com there are many tunings to choose from...hope that was not too long, and i hope it helps. john [This message has been edited by Administrator Freed (edited 03-05-2006).] IP: Logged |
|
john brenton New Member Posts: 2 From: fresno ca eeuu Registered: Mar 2006 |
http://pacoweb.net/Cuerdas/cuechara.htm is actually the site that anyone interested in all sorts of charango tunings would want to visit. sorry if i gave a bad direction before. Juan IP: Logged |
|
Roblawmusic New Member Posts: 3 From: Darwin, NT, Australia Registered: Jul 2006 |
Gday Massiel, I overcame the holding problem simply by attaching a strap to it. You can do this by drilling a careful small hole about 6 cms up from the base on the back of the instrument (i.e.closest to right elbow-if your right handed!), and putting in a strap nut. It frees it up immensely, and helps you jump around when the rhythms take over! Cheers, rob. IP: Logged |
|
Finn Bjerke Member ![]() Posts: 2614 From: www.finnbjerke.dk Registered: Apr 2000 |
Ok I have one these small monsters now, I know Im daft, but regarding tuning G/G Is that G4 or G3 ? Tuning low string to G4 makes me (too) nervous tuning too G3 results in the charango goes out of tune.. Gawd Im neurotic.. Well Ill try the Brozmann version after all this is not a cello.. I have a thing about stringing too hard.. [This message has been edited by Finn Bjerke (edited 08-19-2006).] IP: Logged |
|
Finn Bjerke Member ![]() Posts: 2614 From: www.finnbjerke.dk Registered: Apr 2000 |
This here Charango is TOO MUCH FUN... If you dont have one get one.. IP: Logged |
|
ron6827 Member Posts: 46 From: Registered: Jun 2004 |
Charango, traditional 10-stringed Andean instrument, tuned ggcceEaaee low to high IP: Logged |
|
ron6827 Member Posts: 46 From: Registered: Jun 2004 |
Charango, traditional 10-stringed Andean instrument, tuned ggcceEaaee low to high. I forgot, you can start out with standard ukulele chords by ignoring the high ee strings. IP: Logged |
All times are PST (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
©1999,2000,2001,2002, 2003,2004,2005,2006 IGS. All Rights Reserved
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board