| Please CLICK HERE to go to the updated guitar forum. This version is no longer active as a discussion area, but is still available as a searchable archive. All user names and passwords have been integrated in the new forum |
|
Acoustic Guitar Forum
![]() The IGS Guitar Forum
![]() Covers of Rev Gary Davis' Delia
|
| next newest topic | next oldest topic |
| Author | Topic: Covers of Rev Gary Davis' Delia |
|
Cham Rand Member Posts: 19 From: New Jersey Registered: May 2000 |
I heard Woody play this tune again yesterday at the Mix-o-lydian studios and posted a follow-up on his forum about the tune. He said he thought that there was a Davis cover available but he wasn't sure where. He suggested I poll the experts here. I searched the forums here and found an earlier thread that mentioned Martin Simpson's "Cool & Unusual" but I don't see the tune listed on it (maybe under another name?). A quick search of CDNow only turned up a cover by Roy Bookbinder on his "Travelin' Man" album (which sounded pretty good). Any other covers around of the tune? Tab? Any clues would be helpful. Thanks! [This message has been edited by Cham Rand (edited 04-30-2001).] IP: Logged |
|
Stu Alt Member Posts: 958 From: Arizona Registered: Nov 1999 |
"Smoke & Mirrors" is the Martin Simpson disc with Delia on it. Johnny Cash covered it, too. IP: Logged |
|
~(,@)===::: Member Posts: 280 From: Washington DC Registered: Mar 2000 |
Cham Rand, This is a great tune. I learned it a few months ago from a tab from one of Martins classes at IGS. Martins arrangement is excellent but almost impossible to sing and play. I would be interested in hearing a few other versions to understand where Martin was coming from. If anybody else out there knows this tune I would like to discuss some fingering and picking techniques. Jim IP: Logged |
|
dmills Member Posts: 183 From: Santa Cruz, CA, USA Registered: Feb 2000 |
My favorite rendition of Delia is on an old David Bromberg album. It's one of the first songs I ever learned straight from a recording. Near the end of the song, Bromberg talks about a Blind Willie McTell version, which I've never heard. IP: Logged |
|
drDAve Member Posts: 739 From: Lake Oswego Registered: Sep 2000 |
Cham Rand Woody played that version of Delia last year at the teacher concert at IGS and it was one of the best things I heard that week. I would love to learn his version but don't have it recorded. Martin's version is quite different but also great-it appears on smoke and mirrors and his Bootleg USA album. I have the tab from Martin for it-not really very difficult to play once you figure out the fingering. Singing along is, as someone mentioned, quite another matter. Martin has an amazing ability to seperate his vocals from his guitar with regard to time and phrasing so as to come up with two seperate lines that fit perfectly (take a listen to how he pulls time around on Boots of Spanish Leather)-no doubt it's only a matter of ten or fifteen years of dilligent practice! Bromberg has a straightforward version on his greatest hits album. I've never heard Gary Davis do Delia, but I do have a Willie McTell recording-his version is incredibly harsh-it's told more from the point of view of the killer, and not poor Delia, and the killer isn't too sorry about what he did. Cool how a song can evolve and take on so many personas. IP: Logged |
|
Cham Rand Member Posts: 19 From: New Jersey Registered: May 2000 |
Thanks for all of the great information about the tune! What a wonderful resource this is. Cheers! IP: Logged |
|
Grits unregistered |
Bob Dylan does a great version of the Blind Willie variation on "World Gone Wrong." The Cash song sounds more like "Ella Speed" by Mance Lipscomb... IP: Logged |
|
Adrian Freed Member ![]() Posts: 2360 From: Berkeley, CA, USA Registered: Oct 2000 |
Delia - Davis, Gary (Rev.) Rt - Delia's Gone/Delia 1. Bookbinder, Roy. Travelin' Man, Adelphi AD 1017, LP (1972), cut#A.02 Delia (Holmes) [Laws I 4] Rt - Delia's Gone/Delia 1. Native American Balladry, Amer. Folklore Society, Bk (1964/1950), p248 Delia's Fling - Russo, Mike 1. Russo, Mike. Mike Russo, Arhoolie 4003, LP (197?), cut#A.05 Delia's Gone/Delia [Laws I 4] Rt - Delia ; Delia (Holmes) Uf - In The Pines 1. Songs for Pickin' and Singin', Gold Medal Books, sof (1962), p 19 IP: Logged |
|
outfidel Member ![]() Posts: 1686 From: Ridgewood, NJ Registered: Jul 2001 |
Over on the Mudcat Cafe, they say that Blind Willie McTell and Blind Blake also recorded Delia. Also, here's the story behind the song, as posted by John Garst on the Mudcat: quote: IP: Logged |
|
Jeffrey Sipress Member ![]() Posts: 1335 From: Santa Barbara, CA Registered: Nov 1999 |
Hey, Where's CornDog when you need him?!? IP: Logged |
|
Cham Rand Member Posts: 19 From: New Jersey Registered: May 2000 |
Outfidel, what a great find! I'd forgotten about this post. That the beauty of this Forum. IP: Logged |
|
SHG Member Posts: 67 From: Teaneck, NJ, USA Registered: Jul 2003 |
Ernie Hawkins covers Delia on his most recent CD (he spells it DEHLIA - and attributes it to Blind Willie McTell as well as RGD) IP: Logged |
|
bcw unregistered |
i believe sparky rucker does a nice version of delia. IP: Logged |
|
MikeT Member Posts: 36 From: Fort Collins, CO-USA Registered: Nov 2002 |
In my foggy memory, Didn't Grossman do a version of this in one of his albums, or one of his "training" tapes/CD's/Books? That's the one I remember. IP: Logged |
|
eddie walker New Member Posts: 2 From: England Registered: Nov 2007 |
All The Friends I Ever Had Are Gone by RGD and BWMcT use most of the same lyrics. This is Bromberg's and Grossman's version and Roy Bookbinder too (on his first album Travelling Man) often just called Delia. Delis's Gone is a different song as performed by Pete Seeger circa 1947 (tho' I haven't heard it), told to me and covered by Happy Traum in the 70s on American Stranger. He taught it to me in dropped 'D' tuning. Kind of more Joseph Spence than anything. Certainly not RGDs Piedmont style played in 'C'that was a totally different tune. Then I met a woman whose family had lived and worked in the West Indies for the British Foreign Office and she had a 78rpm record of Delia's Gone picked up there, Jamaica I think. It worked more off a calypso beat, up tempo more verses, and had tongue in cheek lyrics something like....the judge he says I'm gonna give you 99....so what... I gotta brother down in New Orleans doing 9 hundred and 99...ho ho ho! And these ironic verses had been dropped by Happy to leave the poignent ones and a much better song. The Cash version in my humble opinion is dreadful like most everything else he did. And typically he keeps the worst of the lyrics and thinks that's ok cos I'm me! Bad judgement mate! IP: Logged |
|
ben's dad Member Posts: 150 From: Registered: Jul 2003 |
For what it's worth there is a nice version of this song on the album, "Nod to Bob" (a tribute album to Dylan) done by Spider John Koerner and David Ray. In fact the whole CD is pretty good with a killer "I Want You" by Cliff Eberhardt, whom I had never heard of before. Also the aforementioned "Boots of Spanish Leather" by Martin Simpson and "Girl from the North Country" by John Gorka are included and are jewels. Don Bendig IP: Logged |
|
Stu Alt Member Posts: 958 From: Arizona Registered: Nov 1999 |
McTell's version of Delia is on Disc 4 of the JSP box set Blind Willie McTell "The Classic Years 1927-1940" IP: Logged |
|
ringfinger Member Posts: 131 From: australia Registered: Jan 2007 |
quote: It's in his Ragtime Blues Guitarists book which I purchased around 1976 an stiill have (it's looking a little bit ragtimed itself after so long). Grossman gives joint copyright to the tablature to Rev Gary Davis and himself but provides two sets of lyrics; the first by Davis and the second by Blind Willie McTell. IP: Logged |
|
Mr. Natural Member Posts: 10 From: antwerp, belgium Registered: May 2005 |
Eric Taylor does a fine version/medley (11:37 !) called "Delia/Bad News" on his Scuffletown cd. Superb sogwriting & singing. Check him out. Ed IP: Logged |
|
The_Big_Crunch Member Posts: 65 From: Silver Spring, MD, USA Registered: Mar 2007 |
On the "Live at the Fur Peace Ranch" album, Roy Bookbinder says that he learned the song from RGD, who claims Delia was from Georgia and that he knew her. How much of that was RGD exagerating or Roy exagerating is out of my jurisdiction, but as I recall, Roy said that RGD claimed she was a Georgia girl, who was killed in 1910. Interesting how these things get their own lives. If that newspaper article is true, then much of the song is wrong. Delia wasn't a gambler, she wasn't killed by a .44, and she wasn't killed by "Cutty". FWIW, I've always thought the Cash version was sort've weak, and I like a lot of JC's music and just about everything else on that album. IP: Logged |
|
Doc Brainerd Member Posts: 72 From: Tualatin, OR USA Registered: Aug 2006 |
For a detail discussion of the song "Delia's Gone" - and also "Stagger Lee" and "Frankie and Albert" - check out "The Rose & the Briar: Death, Love and Liberty in the American Ballad" (eds. Sean Wilent and Greil Marcus). DB IP: Logged |
|
eddie walker New Member Posts: 2 From: England Registered: Nov 2007 |
Roy spent a lot of time with RGD in the late 60s and Woody Mann too, yeah. Over here in Britain Derek Brimstone drove Gary around on tour in the mid 60s and Derek had Delia/All The Friends I Had Are Gone in his repertoire before Grossman's Oak/Music Sales tab books were available (printed first in 1970). I dug out my copy to read what Stefan had put down there (always interesting stuff) and he talks of BWMcTs version called Delia or the short version that is All My Friends Are Gone and as has just been posted by ringfinger gives two different verse sets, tho' its basically the same song when Delias Gone surely isn't. But then I get my gatefold Atlanta Twelve String album out, Blues Originals Vol. 1 on Atlantic SD 7224, the originals produed in '49 by Ahmet Ertegun (read about how he found Willie on the street in Atlanta and took him to a recording studio straight off, in Michael Gray's recent biography of BWMcT, Hand Me My Travellin Shoes, it's a fantastic read if you have an interest in the history of a truly great original guitar hero) and the album has the song listed as Little Delia, that hasn't been yet mentioned. Now we know Willie stole stuff for himself. (King Edward's Blues is a pop song of its day, Baby It Must Be Love, that must have been written after late '36 of course, but Willie changed the title and claimed authorship). But how did Willie McTell get RGDs version of what he called Little Delia if that was the way round it passed? We know it isn't the same song, same guitar styling as Delia's Gone but Willies and Garys are close in their guitar styling. I'm still fascinated how such a difinitive piece of music was passed around then. Any thoughts anyone? IP: Logged |
All times are PST (US) | next newest topic | next oldest topic |
![]() |
|
©1999,2000,2001,2002, 2003,2004,2005,2006 IGS. All Rights Reserved
Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board